Vacuum Packaging (VP)
Vacuum packaging removes air from the package and can reduce the growth of aerobic spoilage organisms, thereby extending shelf life. Smoked fish is commonly vacuum packed for these reasons. However, VP does not provide an effective control measure for Listeria monocytogenes, which is able to survive and grow under chilled, low-oxygen conditions (EFSA opinion).
In one study, L. monocytogenes counts on unsmoked fish increased by approximately 1 log after one week at 4°C and by up to 4 logs after five weeks³⁶. This demonstrates that VP does not inhibit growth when fish provides a suitable nutrient substrate.
Across studies, findings are inconsistent regarding the effect of smoking prior to VP³⁷–³⁹. Nilsson et al. observed increases from 3 to 8 log cfu/g over 8 days at 4°C³⁸, whereas Porsby and colleagues reported decreases following smoking⁴⁰. Discrepancies are likely to reflect differences in experimental design, including the use of artificial inoculation, strain characteristics (including sessile versus planktonic phenotypes) and inoculum size³⁹.
Evidence from naturally contaminated products indicates that growth is strongly influenced by storage temperature. Lappi and colleagues examined naturally contaminated smoked salmon under refrigerated VP for 28 days and found L. monocytogenes levels remained below the EU Regulation 2073/2005 limit of 100 cfu/g⁴¹. A large French study of over 1,000 samples reported initial prevalence ranging from 0 to 41%, with more than 92% of samples containing less than 1 cfu/g³⁹. After storage at 4°C, counts were unchanged, whereas after storage at 8°C (representative of domestic refrigeration), 17% of samples exceeded 100 cfu/g, with a maximum of 2,800 cfu/g. These results demonstrate that even low initial contamination can result in proliferation under suboptimal refrigeration.
Packaging atmosphere also influences spoilage and quality outcomes. One study compared VP and modified atmosphere packaging (MAP) for smoked trout over 60 days⁴². MAP (70% N₂ / 30% CO₂) consistently yielded lower microbial counts and better sensory scores. Total volatile base-nitrogen (TVB-N) exceeded spoilage thresholds after 45 days, indicating that the nominal 60-day shelf life was excessive. A meta-review concluded that MAP, particularly atmospheres with high CO₂ or N₂, more reliably extends shelf life than VP⁴³.
In summary, L. monocytogenes can multiply under VP during chilled storage. While salt and smoke residues may delay growth, VP alone is not an effective control or elimination measure.
Carbon Dioxide-Based MAP
Modified atmosphere packaging gases are regulated as food additives under EC 95/2, EC 1333/2008, and relevant UK labelling laws (such as The Food Labelling Regulations 1996). Carbon dioxide–based MAP is widely used in smoked fish to slow spoilage and extend shelf life, but its effect on Listeria monocytogenes is primarily inhibitory rather than eliminative.
Nilsson and colleagues found that L. monocytogenes on cold-smoked salmon packed in 70% CO₂ / 30% N₂ exhibited an 8-day lag phase, compared with a 5-log increase under VP38. However, growth resumed after 27–44 days, confirming that inhibition was temporary. Szabo and Cahill reported complete suppression of L. monocytogenes growth at refrigeration and mild abuse temperatures when 100% CO₂ was combined with bacteriocins (nisin or ALTA 2341)44. Muratore and Licciardello found shorter sensory shelf life for swordfish in MAP (12 days) than VP (42 days), despite similar microbial loads, indicating CO₂ may adversely affect product organoleptics45.
A study tested various MAP compositions on rainbow trout and found that all reduced growth rates compared with air or VP, though none eliminated L. monocytogenes. After 18 days, MAP B (80% O₂ / 20% CO₂) yielded the lowest count (~5.5 log cfu/g), but differences were not statistically analysed46.
MAP with high CO₂ can delay L. monocytogenes growth but not prevent it. Practical issues include the need for higher gas-to-product ratios, increasing packaging volume and environmental impact. CO₂ emitters may mitigate this47, but no studies have evaluated their effect on L. monocytogenes in smoked fish. Hansen and co-workers reported that CO₂ emitters maintained total counts < 50 cfu/g for 14 days on raw fish stored at 0.1 °C47.
Overall, CO₂-based MAP can delay L. monocytogenes proliferation by up to 7 days under ideal refrigeration but does not eradicate the organism. Any meaningful control effect is dependent on combination with other hurdles, such as approved antimicrobials. MAP products must also be clearly labelled “packaged in a protective atmosphere.”