- L. monocytogenes can exist in two forms: free-swimming (planktonic) cells and sessile cells in a biofilm. Biofilms are a common route for persistence in a food processing plant.
- Planktonic cells are more susceptible to cleaning and sanitisation, while biofilm-associated bacteria may require 10–20 times more chemical and additional strategies, such as prolonged scrubbing, for removal.
- Sub-lethal chemical exposure within biofilms may promote resistance to sanitising agents.
- Biofilms are complex, often containing multiple bacterial species, which may variably inhibit or support L. monocytogenes growth.
Listeria monocytogenes can exist as planktonic cells, meaning individual or small groups of cells dispersed in liquid and not attached to a surface, or as sessile cells embedded in an extracellular polymer matrix forming a biofilm. Cells growing on moist surfaces may begin in a planktonic state before attaching and developing into a biofilm under favourable conditions.1,2. Planktonic cells are readily controlled with standard cleaning and sanitisation agents. By contrast, biofilm-associated L. monocytogenes requires 10–20 times more chemical to achieve equivalent kill rates and may require additional mechanical action such as prolonged scrubbing3.
Biofilms in processing environments may expose bacteria to sub-lethal concentrations of sanitising chemicals, particularly if cleaning is imperfect4. Repeated sub-lethal exposure can promote resistance to quaternary ammonium and phenolic sanitisers. Evidence suggests biofilm growth can contribute to temporary plant persistence, although resistance to sanitisers does not directly correlate with long-term plant residency5. Persistence appears to be largely stochastic, driven by environmental niches where disinfectants cannot fully penetrate. In these protected sites, biofilm formation can provide an additional advantage by helping cells tolerate sanitiser exposure, allowing temporary persistence even when planktonic cells would be removed6-8. Organic residues left by imperfect cleaning can further impede effective sanitation7.
Heir and co-workers assessed L. monocytogenes competitiveness in biofilms alone, with other L. monocytogenes strains, with other Listeria species, and within mixed Gram-positive and Gram-negative communities. Biofilm formation occurred under all conditions, but L. monocytogenes growth was reduced in mixed-species biofilms, particularly when competing with Pseudomonas or Listeria innocua, and suppression was amplified by background Gram-negative microbiota. This demonstrates that biofilm formation and competitive success vary by strain and environmental context. Papaioannou and colleagues evaluated six L. monocytogenes strains on stainless steel under simulated fish processing conditions, alone or with four Pseudomonas strains or natural fish microbiota10. Biofilms formed more effectively in monoculture. Mixed-species biofilms, particularly with indigenous microbiota, suppressed L. monocytogenes growth. They also exposed sessile cells in a biofilm to two commercial sanitisers: Hypofoam VF6 (chlorinated alkali) and Divosan SU 319/VT8w (quaternary ammonium). Neither fully eradicated monoculture biofilms, with resistance observed between days 3 and 7. Biofilms containing natural microbiota were fully destroyed, likely due to the low number of L. monocytogenes cells. The study concluded that the seafood industry should consider mixed-species interactions when designing anti-biofilm strategies.
Another study investigated commercial sanitisers (hydrogen peroxide and quaternary ammonium) on single-strain and multi-strain biofilms in both laboratory and commercial facility settings11. Neither completely eradicated L. monocytogenes, and some cells entered a viable but non-culturable state (VBNC). Surfaces testing negative for L. monocytogenes via standard microbiology may still harbour VBNC cells capable of resuming growth and potentially causing illness.