- Hot smoking can serve as a critical control point (CCP), provided that the process conditions are appropriately validated.
- Different time–temperature combinations are used in production protocols, highlighting the importance of product-specific validation.
- A table below shows validated time–temperature combinations for a range of products, which may be used as reference when carrying out CCP validation.
- F- and D-values used to calculate bacterial reductions are discussed.
Hot smoking
In summary:
Temperature as a Critical Control Point in Hot Smoking
Hot smoking meets the Food and Agriculture Organisation of the United Nations (FAO) criteria for a critical control point (CCP) and therefore presents an opportunity to improve the food safety of a fish process1. When hot smoking is performed as planned and a critical temperature is achieved for a defined duration across all fillets in a batch, it can render the product completely free of L. monocytogenes2,3.
With respect to L. monocytogenes, successful achievement of the CCP means that conditions before the thermal processing stage become less important. However, there remain other hazards in fish smoking that are not effectively controlled by temperature alone (see Chemical Hazards in Fish and Microbiological Hazards in Fish).
The specific temperature required to control L. monocytogenes remains contentious, with credible sources advising different targets: The Scottish and UK Food Standards Agencies, the European Salmon Smokers’ Association, FAO, the Canadian Government, and the USDA/US-FDA do not stipulate a defined temperature for L. monocytogenes control in hot smoked fish. Sikorski and Kolodziejska proposed that this may be because thermal tolerance varies between L. monocytogenes strains and depends on product composition1,4.
Food Standards Australia advises that L. monocytogenes cannot survive above 75 °C (no hold time specified). Informed industry associations, such as the US National Fisheries Institute and the US National Food Processors Association, recommend 62.8 °C for 30 minutes as sufficient for control.
Several studies indicate that bacterial death results from the combined effect of temperature, phenolic compounds in smoke, and salt concentration in the fish muscle acting synergistically1,4,5.
Numerous peer-reviewed studies have reported reductions in L. monocytogenes populations following heat treatment, with or without consideration of smoke and salt concentrations. Some conclude that appropriate thermal processes can completely eliminate L. monocytogenes contamination from fish. A summary of these studies and key findings is provided in Table 1.
Table 1: A summary of reported CCP temperatures in hot smoked seafood that caused a reduction in L. monocytogenes populations. F values are calculated as 12 x D-values.
| Core temp. (oC) | Duration (min) | Product | Effective control achieved? | Other considerations | Reference |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 62 | F (calculated): 26
(Actual duration not specified) | Crab meat | Unclear | Inoculated a single strain of L. monocytogenes at 107 cfu/g. Actual temperature with extrapolated duration from D values. Study criticism that the crab meat was blended and packed into sausage casing and heat was applied using a hot water bath. | Harrison and Huang (1990)6 |
| 65 | F (calculated): 3.2
(Actual duration not specified) | Crawfish tail meat | Unclear | Inoculated a two-strain cocktail of L. monocytogenes at just over 103 cfu/g. Actual temperature with extrapolated duration from D values. Study criticism that the tail meat was previously cooked, frozen, thawed and then used for the experiments. | Dorsa et al. (1993)7 |
| 62.7 | F (calculated): 13.2
(Actual duration not specified) | Lobster | Unclear | Inoculated a five-strain cocktail of L. monocytogenes at 107 cfu/g. Actual temperature with extrapolated duration from D values. Study criticism that heat was was applied to pouches of shredded lobster immersed in a hot water bath. | Budo-Amoako et al. (1992)8 |
| 65 | 20 | Trout | Yes | Inoculated single strain of L. monocytogenes at 106 MPN/g. Complete kill observed. | Jemmi and Keusch (1992)2 |
| 62 | 18.5 | Blended mussels | Unclear | Inoculated a seven-strain cocktail of L. monocytogenes at 106 cfu/25g mussels, temperature and duration extrapolated from D values. | Bremer and Osborne (1995)9 |
| 67.2 | Unclear, there was stepwise increase of temperature; higher temperature meant longer duration | Salmon | Dependent on temperature applied and exposure to smoke | Inoculated a two-strain cocktail of L. monocytogenes at 330-350 cfu/25g, effective killing at the temperature required exposure to smoke. | Poysky et al. (1997)1 |
| >82.8 | Salmon | Inoculated a two-strain cocktail of L. monocytogenes at 330-350 cfu/25g, no smoke was required for effective kill at higher temperature. | Poysky et al. (1997)1 | ||
| ≤60 | 85 | Mackerel | No | Natural contamination of 102-104 aerobes/g fish, heat treatment was insufficient to destroy all aerobes. | Kolodziejska et al. (2002)10 |
| 55 | 360 | Salmon | No | Inoculated a six-strain cocktail of L. monocytogenes at 106 cfu/g, using 6% salt and 15ppm phenols, the fish were still contaminated with L. monocytogenes. | Hwang et al. (2009)5 |
| 72 | 6 | Tench | Yes | Inoculated a three-strain cocktail of L. innocua as a L. monocytogenes surrogate; inoculated at 105 cfu/g. Complete kill observed. | Branciari et al. (2016)3 |
F-, D-, and Z-values and Their Application
There are glossary entries for D-, Z-, and F-values, which users may wish to review before reading this section. It should be stressed that F is unrelated to the Fahrenheit temperature scale.
As noted above, defining absolute criteria for temperature and hold duration is difficult because bacterial strain variation and physiological state influence thermal tolerance. This variability is common across food microbiology, not just in L. monocytogenes in smoked fish.
Critical control points are defined as process stages that either eliminate a hazard or reduce it to an acceptable level. A widely accepted approach in food microbiology is to calculate an F-value from an experimentally derived D-value at a specific temperature. F is defined as the time at a given temperature required to achieve a 12-log reduction in bacterial numbers. D is defined as the time required at a specific temperature to reduce a bacterial population by 90% (one log). For example, if heating a sample at 74°C for one minute reduces Listeria monocytogenes from 1,000 to 100 cells, the D-value is 1. D-values are used to assess how effectively heat or other bactericidal treatments inactivate bacteria.
However, the number of log reductions needed to reduce L. monocytogenes to an acceptable level is a decision for the FBO, potentially in consultation with their environmental health officer. Tocmo and co-workers reported that L. monocytogenes counts above 10⁴ cfu/g were rare in smoked fish surveillance11. Jami et al. undertook a broader review, with similar findings; levels above 10⁴ cfu/g were possible but uncommon12.
The conventional use of F = 12 × D originates from controls for Clostridium spores in canned or vacuum-packed foods and represents a highly conservative approach. Applying the same 12×D criterion for vegetative bacteria would strongly support a defence of due diligence. Some FBOs may instead consider F = 6 × D acceptable, given that L. monocytogenes rarely exceeds 10⁴ cfu/g at retail and that this reduction would effectively control the hazard.
Experimental evidence supports this reasoning: Shie and Park observed a six-log reduction in total mesophilic aerobic counts during surimi seafood cooking, which Himelbloom considered to represent an effective CCP13,14.
[CP1]Hyperlinks to the respective Glossary entry
References:
- Poysky, F.T., Paranjpye, R.N., Peterson, M.E., Pelroy, G.A., Guttman, A.E. and Eklund, M.W. (1997) Inactivation of Listeria monocytogenes on hot-smoked salmon by the interaction of heat and smoke or liquid smoke. Journal of Food Protection 60, 649-654.
- Jemmi, T. and Keusch, A. (1992) Behaviour of Listeria monocytogenes during processing and storage of experimentally contaminated hot-smoked trout. International Journal of Food Microbiology 15, 339-346.
- Branciari, R., Valiani, A., Franceschini, R., Ranucci, D., Lupattelli, A., Urbani, E. and Ortenzi, R. (2016) Thermal inactivation and growth potential of Listeria monocytogenes in smoked tench. Italian journal of food safety 5, 5974-5974.
- Sikorski, Z.E. and Kolodziejska, I. (2002) Microbial risks in mild hot smoking of fish. Critical Reviews in Food Science and Nutrition 42, 35-51.
- Hwang, C.-A., Sheen, S. and Juneja, V.K. (2009) Effect of Salt, Smoke Compound, and Temperature on the Survival of Listeria monocytogenes in Salmon during Simulated Smoking Processes. Journal of Food Science 74, M522-M529.
- Harrison, M.A. and Huang, Y.-W. (1990) Thermal death times for Listeria monocytogenes (Scott A) in crabmeat. Journal of Food Protection 53, 878-880.
- Dorsa, W.J., Marshall, D.L., Moody, M.W. and Hackney, C.R. (1993) Low temperature growth and thermal inactivation of Listeria monocytogenes in precooked crawfish tail meat. Journal of Food Protection 56, 106-109.
- Budo-Amoako, E., Toora, S., Walton, C., Ablett, R.F. and Smith, J. (1992) Thermal death times for Listeria monocytogenes in lobster meat. Journal of Food Protection 55, 211-213.
- Bremer, P.J. and Osborne, C.M. (1995) Thermal-death times of Listeria monocytogenes in green shell mussels (Perna canaliculus) prepared for hot smoking Journal of Food Protection 58, 604-608.
- Kolodziejska, I., Niecikowska, C., Januszewska, E. and Sikorski, Z.E. (2002) The microbial and sensory quality of mackerel hot smoked in mild conditions. Lebensmittel-Wissenschaft Und-Technologie-Food Science and Technology 35, 87-92.
- Tocmo, R., Krizman, K., Khoo, W.J., Phua, L.K., Kim, M. and Yuk, H.-G. (2014) Listeria monocytogenes in vacuum-packed smoked fish products: Occurrence, routes of contamination, and potential intervention measures. Comprehensive Reviews in Food Science and Food Safety 13, 172-189.
- Jami, M., Ghanbari, M., Zunabovic, M., Domig, K.J. and Kneifel, W. (2014) Listeria monocytogenes in Aquatic Food Products—A Review. Comprehensive Reviews in Food Science and Food Safety 13, 798-813.
- Shie, J.S. and Park, J.W. (1999) Physical characteristics of surimi seafood as affected by thermal processing conditions. Journal of Food Science 64, 287-290.
- Himelbloom, B.H., Price, R.J. Lee, J.S. (2000) Microbiology and HACCP in surimi seafood. In: Surimi and surimi seafood. New York: Published: Marcel Decker Inc. Edited: Park, J.W.