- A multidisciplinary team should be established to investigate and implement corrective actions. External consultants may be used to fill knowledge gaps. Many food business operators (FBOs) also include an Environmental Health Officer (EHO) in this team.
- Work though a series of considerations to determine contamination source and mitigation methods e.g. HACCP review, cleaning procedures, historical test results, personnel movements and hygiene, moisture and drainage and typing to understand relatedness of isolates.
Actions After an Isolation
In summary:
Actions Following a Positive Isolation of L. monocytogenes
If not already in place, a multidisciplinary response team should be formed to address the implications of the isolation. Spanu and Jordan provide detailed guidance on assembling a team with appropriate expertise1. Membership should include senior management (to ensure findings are acted upon), technical and cleaning staff, and personnel with microbiological experience. External consultants can fill technical knowledge gaps as needed. Many FBOs find it beneficial to include EHOs or other enforcement officers in the HACCP review team.
The team should review the following areas to consider the source, risk of spread within the plant and potential mitigation steps:
Review of HACCP and Control Systems
A first step following an isolation is to review HACCP plans and associated monitoring records to determine whether any process failures or gaps in monitoring contributed to the event. This review is often conducted as an unannounced audit.
For fish processes such as cold smoking, there are typically very few critical control points (CCPs) capable of effectively controlling L. monocytogenes. Consequently, investigations in these cases should focus on the prerequisite programmes, including supply chain controls, sanitation, and operational hygiene, rather than CCPs alone.
Cleaning and Equipment Assessment
The review should include an assessment of cleaning effectiveness, particularly the cleaning of complex or difficult-to-disassemble machinery. Standard operating procedures, cleaning frequencies, and chemical concentrations should all be reviewed. Ideally, a plant engineer should assist during the audit to support equipment disassembly.
Poorly designed or damaged processing equipment is a well-documented source of persistent L. monocytogenes contamination. A robust audit will inspect the plant before production for the day begins, noting any areas that remain soiled after cleaning, especially with food residues. The most thorough audits also include microbiological sampling from disassembled equipment and from areas identified as poorly cleaned.
Tracing and Environmental Mapping
Historical isolation data are a valuable diagnostic tool. Plotting previous L. monocytogenes isolations on a plant floor plan can reveal geographical trends or potential involvement of infrastructure elements such as drains in pathogen spread.
Suspected problem areas should be investigated with targeted sampling, ideally using surfaces and timings that differ from the plant’s routine monitoring. Sampling both before and during processing can reveal resident L. monocytogenes populations that emerge only once operations commence.
Personnel and Equipment Movement
Staff and equipment movement between low-care and high-care areas must be tightly controlled. Clothing and footwear must not be shared between zones, and barriers protecting the high-care area must not be circumvented. The movements of maintenance staff and their tools should also be reviewed, as they are common vectors for cross-contamination.
Maintaining a Dry Environment
Maintaining a dry processing environment is one of the most effective control strategies2,3. Many large processors prohibit water use in the high-care area (HCA) during routine production.
Best practices include:
- Removing all non-essential hoses from the HCA.
- Using dry-cleaning techniques (e.g. squeegees) to remove debris during production.
- Relocating equipment requiring wet cleaning to dedicated anterooms outside the HCA.
These anterooms are typically fitted with elevated thresholds to contain water and equipped with raised mesh flooring to prevent splash-back. Ideally, they are situated close to drain exits to prevent contaminated water from entering the processing halls.
Drainage and Structural Integrity
Drainage should always flow from high-care to low-care areas. Blocked drains can reverse this flow and transfer L. monocytogenes into high-care zones. Drains should be inspected and cleared immediately following any isolation event.
Cracked or damaged floors, walls, or drains must be repaired promptly, as such defects can harbour resident L. monocytogenes. Roofs and external drainage systems should also be maintained; blocked or damaged guttering can allow contaminated water ingress.
There is evidence that equipment replacement or refurbishment can disturb and release previously contained contamination. Any new isolations following such work should be assessed in that context.
Air Pressure and Hygiene Audits
Positive air pressure systems in the HCA should be verified to ensure air movement is always from inside to outside.
Audits should also review employee hygiene, including handwashing and glove replacement frequency. Hand and glove swabs may be taken to verify compliance. Gloves can become contaminated if dispensers are cleaned improperly or during nearby wet cleaning. Dispensers should be emptied before cleaning, and random checks of gloves can confirm sterility.
Personal lockers may be searched to ensure utensils or equipment are not stored improperly.
Typing and Source Discrimination
Where no clear contamination trend emerges, molecular typing can distinguish whether a single persistent strain is responsible or whether multiple unrelated isolates are present. This information can help to determine whether contamination originates from the processing environment or from incoming raw materials. Further guidance on L. monocytogenes typing is provided in the corresponding section.
References:
- Spanu, C. and Jordan, K. (2020) Listeria monocytogenes environmental sampling program in ready-to-eat processing facilities: A practical approach. Comprehensive Reviews in Food Science and Food Safety 19, 2843-2861.
- Jami, M., Ghanbari, M., Zunabovic, M., Domig, K.J. and Kneifel, W. (2014) Listeria monocytogenes in aquatic food products—A review. Comprehensive Reviews in Food Science and Food Safety 13, 798-813.
- Overney, A., Jacques-Andre-Coquin, J., Ng, P., Carpentier, B., Guillier, L. and Firmesse, O. (2017) Impact of environmental factors on the culturability and viability of Listeria monocytogenes under conditions encountered in food processing plants. Int. J. Food Microbiol. 244, 74-81.