Procurement Exercise for the Delivery of Meat Official Controls


1. Please could you provide a breakdown of the individual scores of the individual evaluation panel members? 

2. Could you please confirm the extent to which the original scores of the evaluation panel were amended during the moderation process? 

3. Could you please explain what guidance was given to the evaluation panel with regard to proportionate scoring and giving credit for all positive aspects of any response?

4. Could you please explain what guidance was provided to evaluation panel managers in terms of justifying their scoring? 

5. Could you please provide copies of the individual evaluation panel members’ scoring justification? 

6. Could you please confirm that the evaluation panel members were all completely independent of both HMMH and E&J, in the sense of having no direct or indirect business or personal connection to any representative of the incumbent? 


1. I enclose a copy of the information you requested.

Annex 1 - 5

2. The answer to your question is as follows:

Question 2.1 – Evaluator 4 – original score of “4” - moderation meeting - score of “3”

Question 5.1 – Evaluator 1 – original score of “4” - moderation meeting - score of “3”

Question 5.1 – Evaluator 2 – original score of “4” - moderation meeting - score of “3”

Question 5.1 – Evaluator 4 – original score of “4” - moderation meeting - score of “3”

Question 6.1 – Evaluator 2 – original score of “3” - moderation meeting - score of “2”

Question 6.1 – Evaluator 4 – original score of “4” - moderation meeting - score of “3”

Question 6.2 – Evaluator 3 – original score of “2” - moderation meeting - score of “3”

3. The Technical Evaluation Panel were provided with a guidance document which summarised the award criteria questions/weightings and scoring guide, the same information as detailed in the Instructions to Tenderers (ITT) document provided to Tenderers.  The guide also includes an extract of the ITT, ie Schedule 1 (Specification) and Schedule 4 (Management Information).  I enclose a copy of the Technical Evaluation Guide and embedded Evaluator Scoring Sheet.   

Annex 6 & 7

4. The guidance provided to the evaluation panel members was the same scoring guidance detailed in the ITT document and the Technical Evaluator guide, see Annex 6 & 7. 

5. The individual evaluation panel members scoring justification is provided within the documents in response to question 1. 

6. All technical evaluation panel members are required to complete a Declaration of Impartiality and Confidentiality Form, please see Annex 8.  I can confirm that all evaluators completed this form.  There were representatives on the technical panel who are responsible for contract management of the current contract.

Annex 8

Arrow_Dropdown Created with Sketch. Arrow_leftArrow_Right Icon_AlchoholIcon_Alchohol_RoundalIcon_AppleIcon_Apple_RoundalIcon_BacteriaIcon_Bacteria_Roundal calorie-outlined Created with Sketch. Icon_CardActivityIcon_CardActivity_RoundalIcon_CarrotIcon_Carrot_Roundal Icon/roundal/Allergen/Celery Created with Sketch. Icon_CertificateIcon_Certificate_RoundalIcon_CheeseIcon_Cheese_RoundalIcon_ChocolateIcon_Chocolate_RoundalIcon_ClipboardIcon_Clipboard_Roundal Icon_CloseIcon_CowIcon_Cow_Roundal Shape Created with Sketch. Icon/roundal/Allergen/Crustaceans Created with Sketch. Icon_CursorIcon_Cursor_RoundalIcon_DeerIcon_Deer_RoundalIcon_download Icon/roundal/Allergen/Eggs Created with Sketch. Icon_Facebook_RoundalIcon-FeaturedIcon_Fish Icon/roundal/Allergen/Fish Created with Sketch. Icon_Fish_RoundalIcon_FizzyJuiceIcon_FizzyJuice_RoundalIcon_ForkIcon_Fork_RoundalIcon_FridgeIcon_Fridge_Roundal Icon/roundal/Allergen/Wheat Created with Sketch. Icon_GrainIcon_GrainNoIcon_GrainNo_RoundalIcon_Grain_RoundalIcon_GraphIcon_GraphResourceIcon_Graph_RoundalIcon_HandIcon_Hand_RoundalIcon_HeartIcon_Heart_RoundalIcon_InfoIcon_Info_Roundal instagram Icon_LambIcon_Lamb_RoundalIcon_LetterIcon_Letter_RoundalIcon_LinkExternalIcon_LinkInternal Icon/roundal/Allergen/Lupin Created with Sketch. Icon_MagnifyingGlassIcon_MagnifyingGlass_Roundal Icon/roundal/Allergen/Milk Created with Sketch. Icon/roundal/Allergen/Molluscs Created with Sketch. Icon/roundal/Allergen/Mustrard Created with Sketch. Icon_NewIcon_NewsIcon_News_RoundalIcon_OilIcon_Oil_Roundal Icon/roundal/Allergen/Peanuts Created with Sketch. Icon_PeopleIcon_People_RoundalIcon_PersonIcon_Person_RoundalIcon_PhoneIcon_Phone_RoundalIcon_PigIcon_Pig_RoundalIcon_PlayIcon_PotatoesIcon_Potatoes_RoundalIcon_PrintIcon_Print_RoundalIcon_ResourceIcon_Resource_Roundal Group Created with Sketch. Icon_SaltIcon_Salt_RoundalIcon_SaveIcon_Save_RoundalIcon_ScotlandIcon_Scotland_RoundalIcon_Search Icon/roundal/Allergen/Sesame Seeds Created with Sketch. Icon_ShellfishIcon_Shellfish_Roundal Icon/roundal/Allergen/Soybeans Created with Sketch. Icon-SpiralIcon_SteakIcon_Steak_RoundalIcon_StopwatchIcon_Stopwatch_Roundal Icon/roundal/Allergen/Sulphur dioxide and sulphites Created with Sketch. Icon_TapWaterIcon_TapWater_RoundalIcon_TestTubeIcon_TestTube_RoundalIcon_ThumbsUpIcon_ThumbsUp_RoundalIcon_Tick Shape Created with Sketch. Icon_Tick_1Icon_Tick_Roundal Icon_TomatoIcon_Tomato_RoundalIcon_TractorIcon_Tractor_Roundal Icon/roundal/Allergen/Tree nuts Created with Sketch. Icon_TrollyIcon_Trolly_RoundalIcon_TurkeyIcon_TurkeyCookedIcon_TurkeyCooked_RoundalIcon_Turkey_Roundal Icon_Twitter_RoundalIcon_WarningIcon_Warning_Roundal Icon_Warning_Roundal_WithBG Icon_WaterDropIcon_WaterDrop_RoundalIcon_WineBottleIcon_WineBottle_RoundalIcon_WineGlassIcon_WineGlass_Roundal youtube Icon_snowflakeIcon_snowflake_RoundalLogo_FSS_Gaelic_WhiteLogo_FSS_WhitePagination_LeftArtboard 69